
|
November 2000
Jean Chretien, Stockwell Day, Gilles Duceppe, Joe Clark, Alexa McDonough, Ron Gray Jean
Chretien - Liberal
Speaking in Winnipeg, he said, "We Liberals believe in a woman's
right to choose." (Vancouver Sun, Aug. 31, 2000) "[Stockwell
Day] wants a divisive national debate on this issue ... that is no
way to run this country." He added "To break the social
peace we have had in Canada on this issue ever since the Supreme Court
decision of 1988". (LifeSite News Nov. 7, 2000)
The Hill Times reports that Mr. Chretien said in a late September
caucus meeting that
At St. Joseph's Catholic High School in Barrie, Ont., Mr. Chretien
responded to a question about his position on abortion as follows:
"Personally, I don't have to, you know, I'm not at the age anymore
to have my wife have abortion, but the reality ... is that it is the
choice of not the husband to decide in my judgment, it is the judgment
of the woman according to the values that this person have."
(LifeSite News, Nov. 1, 2000) Mr. Chretien has taken an unapologetic, clear, hard-line stand in favour of abortion rights for women during this election campaign. Stockwell
Day - Canadian Alliance As a provincial legislator in Alberta, he backed an attempt to stop taxpayer funding of abortion. On euthanasia, he said the current law is "satisfactory," but "must be monitored carefully so that it is not weakened."
On reproductive technologies, he said: "I would oppose any NRTs
that involve commercial surrogacy arrangements, the sale of sperm,
eggs, or zygotes, cloning, or genetic manipulation of embryos such
as animal-human hybridization. Existing NRTs such as in-vitro fertilization
and various methods of artificial insemination need to be carefully
regulated."
On governance, he said: "I believe that it is the duty of a democratically
elected representative to be clear about his conscientious beliefs,
and to represent his constituents to the best of his ability by voting
in accordance with his constituents' wishes. However, I believe that
this obligation cannot bind legislators to vote in favour of measures
which would abrogate inalienable human rights, such as the rights
to life, liberty, and property," adding that he believes that
abortion and euthanasia abrogate inalienable human rights.
During the current campaign, Mr. Day has avoided referring to the
abortion issue or providing any arguments supporting his beliefs or
countering in any way his opponents' hard-line stand. He has usually
given brief responses to repeated questioning on abortion, stating
only that he believes that life begins at conception, that "abortion
isn't even on the platform of the party" and that "it should
be talked about in a very respectful way". He also states that
under an Alliance government, citizens would be free to bring different
types of issues to the government via citizen-initiated referendums.
Gilles
Duceppe - Bloc Quebecois
He voted against the marriage motion introduced by the Reform Party
in June last year for the purpose of affirming Parliament's commitment
to a heterosexual definition of marriage. He insisted that all Bloc MPs vote in favour of Bill C-23, giving same-sex partners the same government benefits granted to common-law couples, at final reading, telling those who opposed the legislation not to vote at all, reports Campaign Quebec-Vie. Joe
Clark - Progressive Conservative
He admitted to being "pro-choice" on a radio station in
Atlantic Canada in July of this year.
In the same interview he maintained that the Liberals' recent Bill
C-23 simply extended benefits to same-sex couples, dismissing a caller's
claim that it had any impact on the definition of marriage.
In the current election campaign, he has criticized the Canadian Alliance
over homosexual issues, arguing that his party is very affirming of
homosexuals
During the Nov. 10 leaders debate Clark stated "
I certainly
think that a woman's right to choose has been settled in this country
and it should not be opened again by referenda or by other ways. If
Mr. Day wants to open it, he should have the courage to go out and
open it directly, not to use some indirect, backdoor route such as
a referendum". Alexa
McDonough - NDP
During an exchange with Alliance leader Stockwell Day on Nov. 20 McDonough
stated "I find it absolutely outrageous that Stockwell Day thinks
he can subject my right to choose, my right to make reproductive choices,
my right to control the decisions affecting my own body to a referendum
and start talking about percentages".
Answered euthanasia question in 1997 questionnaire with "neither
yes or no". Said there needs to be "a profound and soul-searching
public discussion". But, in a May 23, 1997 riding debate she
said "we're going to decriminalize the treatment of doctors who
carry out this kind of voluntary request for a merciful death within
guidelines that are clearly and publicly debated and ultimately adopted."
Equality for Gays and Lesbians Everywhere (EGALE) distributed party
leaders' comments on homosexual "marriage" as published
by MuchMusic. Ms. McDonough reportedly said: "Yes, and I voted
that way in the House of Commons. I celebrate love in all its many
forms, and if gay and lesbian couples wish to marry, I support them
and wish them many years of happiness. I'm also the first leader to
ever march in a Pride Parade ..." Ms. McDonough is a vice-president of the Presidium of the Socialist International. Ron
Gray - Christian Heritage |
|||
|