Politics
Wednesday May 3, 2006
See today's LifeSiteNews stories
Canadian Supreme Court’s “Swingers” Ruling Sets Dangerous Precedent, Says Organization
By Gudrun Schultz
OTTAWA, Ontario, May 3, 2006 (LifeSiteNews.com) – Last years’ Supreme Court decision to legalize swinger’s clubs and public group sex in Canada dangerously undermined the concept of “social morality” as a basis for future rulings, according to a review by Canada’s Centre for Cultural Renewal.
Published April 28 in Lex View, the Centre’s analytical review on the social impact of court judgements, the review identifies key areas of concern raised by the decision. The primary issue at stake is the court’s retreat from the concept of social morals as the standard for identifying criminal anti-social behaviour.
The court based the swinger’s club ruling on a standard of “harm”, determining that the club in question was permissible because it did not cause significant harm to the public and society.
“With its cryptic utterance that ‘our concern is not with the moral aspect of indecency but with the legal’, the majority abruptly attempts to sever the moral from the legal and tries to sidestep the appearance of moral reasoning altogether,” authors of the review state.
The two dissenting judges in the decision objected to the narrow definition of “harm” used by the court, saying:
“There are multiple criteria for justifying state intervention in criminal matters, even if it restricts human liberty. Offences under the Criminal Code are thus based on principles and values other than harm…. To place excessive emphasis on the criterion of harm will therefore make it impossible to give effect to the moral principles in respect of which there is a consensus in the community.”
The authors of the review point out the lack of clarity in the decision, which leaves “real uncertainty” about the future application of the harm principle.
“If the Court is tested again on the possession of marijuana for personal use…or on, say, polygamy, or incest between consenting adults (say homosexual sexual incest) how will it respond? Will it move from the harm principle to a larger concept of social morality that may be contemplated in order to safeguard the values that are integral to a free and democratic society? It has left itself little room to do so as the dissenting judges pointed out.”
Read the full review:
http://www.culturalrenewal.ca/qry/page.taf?id=114
See previous LifeSiteNews coverage:
Canada Legalizes "Sex Clubs" - "14-year-olds will be exploited"
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2005/dec/05122104.html
Back to TopSHARE THIS STORY: E-mail Print Newsvine Digg Reddit Del.icio.us Facebook
Latest Headlines
- Petition of 30,000 Canadians Asks Governor General to Rescind Order of Canada to Abortionist
- Lithuanian Government Bans EU Pro-Homosexual Tour Truck
- Australian Woman Dies from Taking Birth Control Pill
- Is it True McCain "Got the Message" About not Running a Pro-Abortion VP?
- Freedom of Conscience for Ontario Doctors: Public Comment Extended to September 12
- Promote Culture of Life and Catholic Teaching to Combat Rising Crime and Cultural Degradation: Lancaster Bishop
- Success with Re-growing Horse Ligaments Leads to New NIH Adult Stem Cell Centre
- Guatemalan Cardinal on Abortion: "It is just as serious to kill a 10 year-old child"
- MP Ken Epp responds to the Abortion Rights Coalition of Canada's Claims about Unborn Victims of Crime Bill
- Health Minister: Safe-Injection Sites a "Surrender to a Culture of Disease and Death."
- Indiana County Commission Upholds Regulations on Abortions under Criticism
- Statistics Canada Finds More Abstinence among Teen Girls in the Last Decade
- Exclusive: Retiring UK Bishop Reveals No Consensus among Brother Bishops over Same-sex Adoption
- California Supreme Court Rules Doctors Must Provide Treatment against Their Religious Beliefs
Most Read this Week
- Westminster Exorcist: Promiscuity can Lead to Demonic Possession
- Secret Meeting to Plot Global Abortion Strategy Exposed - UN Personnel Present
- Batman The Dark Knight - Should We Fear Imitation of the Joker?
- Massive Brazilian Vaccination Raises Suspicions of Covert Sterilization Program
- Niece of Martin Luther King Jr. to Lead Prayer Vigil Outside Largest U.S. Abortion Centre - Monday August 25
- Obama Caught Red-Handed in Abortion Lie
- New England Journal of Medicine: 'Brain Death' is not Death - Organ Donors are Alive
- HPV Vaccine Causes 21 Deaths and Counting - CDC Study Launched
- Traditional Fort Worth Episcopal Priests Seek Communion with Catholic Church
- Homeschooling Showdown in Brazil: Children to be Tested by Court in Battle Over Educational Rights of Parents
MORE NEWS: 
LifeSiteNews.com Home Page Last 10 Days Archives Special Reports
Copyright © LifeSiteNews.com. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivatives License. You may republish this article or portions of it without request provided the content is not altered and it is clearly attributed to "LifeSiteNews.com". Any website publishing of complete or large portions of original LifeSiteNews articles MUST additionally include a live link to www.LifeSiteNews.com. The link is not required for excerpts. Republishing of articles on LifeSiteNews.com from other sources as noted is subject to the conditions of those sources.